SU Critical in a Nutshell

documentingshera-discourse:

weleaveshadows:

• “fucking townie episodes”

• Fifteen paragraphs on how an overarching plot thread wasn’t solved in six episodes
• “WHEN IS X COMING BACK”
• Fundamentally misses the entire point of the show
• Starts complaining about animation three seasons in like they actually care
• Ignores key elements of the show’s presentation in favor of their own imagined narrative
• Equates show’s pacing with factors beyond the creators’ control
• Misinterprets a character completely
• “JASPER/BISMUTH/YD/BD DONT DESERVE TO BE REDEEMED THEYRE ABUSERS
• Fundamentally misses the message of the series
• Complains about plot holes/problems in an arc/mystery that hasn’t been completed yet
• Accuses creators of being horrible after something is portrayed as ~morally ambiguous~~ or *gasp* complex
• Can’t understand basic story structure or pay-off
• Can’t grasp themes even if they’re spelled out for them
• Joins bandwagon of hating the show only after su critical became a trend
• Doesn’t actually contribute any meaningful constructive criticism
• Doesn’t care about literary criticism otherwise
• Ignores actual flaws in storytelling, creates flaws to suit their own agenda
• “It all went downhill after season [x]”
• Claims to hate the show, watches it faithfully regardless

The comments one here shows that SU crits dont have a life outside of the SU crit community